ASHRAE 140 (BESTEST) validation
The building models trano generates are validated against the 27 cases of section 5.2 of ASHRAE
Standard 140-2020 (the BESTEST single-zone cases): a 8 m x 6 m x 2.7 m zone in Denver with light
or heavy constructions, 12 m2 of double glazing, 0.414 air changes per hour of infiltration and
200 W of internal gains, with variants for the insulation, the glazing, the window orientation,
overhangs and side fins, an unconditioned sun-space, free-floating temperatures, a dual set point
ideal system with set-backs and night ventilation.
Each case is a trano YAML file (validation/bestest/cases/), simulated for a year with each
library. The annual heating and cooling loads must fall inside the acceptance limits of the
standard; the peak loads and the free-floating temperatures must fall inside the spread of the
reference programs (BSIMAC, CSE, DeST, EnergyPlus, ESP-r, TRNSYS) widened by 5 % of the largest
peak or 1 K. Buildings and IDEAS are gating libraries: pytest -m bestest fails when one of
their cases leaves its band, except for the deviations listed below with their reason. The
reduced-order (AixLib) and ISO 13790 zones are shown for information: ISO 13790 is a monthly
method applied hour by hour and the reduced-order zone still deviates on several cases, so
neither gates. Cases a library cannot describe (shading with IDEAS, which OpenModelica cannot
compile for IDEAS 3.0.0; shading, sun-space and night ventilation with the two simplified zones)
are left out. The tables are rendered from the last results with
python -m validation.bestest report --docs. A walk through the BESTEST cases explains a few
cases in detail: what they are, what is expected, how the YAML describes them and how the results
compare.
Buildings
| Case |
KPI |
trano |
Band |
Reference mean |
Status |
| 600 |
annual_heating |
4.449 MWh |
3.750 to 4.980 |
4.213 |
pass |
| 600 |
annual_cooling |
5.973 MWh |
5.000 to 6.830 |
5.856 |
pass |
| 600 |
peak_heating |
3.215 kW |
2.852 to 3.527 |
3.183 |
pass |
| 600 |
peak_cooling |
6.187 kW |
5.098 to 6.805 |
6.024 |
pass |
| 610 |
annual_heating |
4.475 MWh |
3.610 to 5.270 |
4.311 |
pass |
| 610 |
annual_cooling |
4.810 MWh |
2.740 to 6.030 |
4.256 |
pass |
| 610 |
peak_heating |
3.216 kW |
2.853 to 3.528 |
3.168 |
pass |
| 610 |
peak_cooling |
6.082 kW |
5.009 to 6.754 |
5.861 |
pass |
| 620 |
annual_heating |
4.563 MWh |
3.670 to 5.380 |
4.413 |
pass |
| 620 |
annual_cooling |
4.087 MWh |
2.760 to 5.190 |
4.090 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_heating |
3.248 kW |
2.869 to 3.554 |
3.186 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_cooling |
4.700 kW |
3.715 to 5.037 |
4.526 |
pass |
| 630 |
annual_heating |
4.746 MWh |
3.690 to 6.120 |
4.822 |
pass |
| 630 |
annual_cooling |
3.320 MWh |
1.080 to 4.420 |
2.814 |
pass |
| 630 |
peak_heating |
3.250 kW |
2.870 to 3.557 |
3.203 |
pass |
| 630 |
peak_cooling |
4.250 kW |
3.315 to 4.423 |
3.963 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_heating |
2.715 MWh |
1.580 to 3.760 |
2.612 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_cooling |
5.725 MWh |
4.440 to 6.860 |
5.636 |
pass |
| 640 |
peak_heating |
4.356 kW |
3.806 to 4.891 |
4.369 |
pass |
| 640 |
peak_cooling |
6.138 kW |
5.044 to 6.750 |
5.973 |
pass |
| 650 |
annual_heating |
0.000 MWh |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 650 |
annual_cooling |
4.802 MWh |
3.460 to 5.880 |
4.644 |
pass |
| 650 |
peak_heating |
0.000 kW |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 650 |
peak_cooling |
5.949 kW |
4.731 to 6.604 |
5.813 |
pass |
| 660 |
annual_heating |
3.620 MWh |
2.680 to 4.820 |
3.713 |
pass |
| 660 |
annual_cooling |
3.315 MWh |
1.910 to 4.330 |
3.172 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_heating |
2.728 kW |
2.472 to 3.103 |
2.801 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_cooling |
3.629 kW |
3.146 to 4.130 |
3.565 |
pass |
| 670 |
annual_heating |
6.473 MWh |
4.000 to 7.960 |
5.681 |
pass |
| 670 |
annual_cooling |
6.361 MWh |
5.050 to 7.670 |
6.402 |
pass |
| 670 |
peak_heating |
4.294 kW |
3.444 to 4.432 |
3.943 |
pass |
| 670 |
peak_cooling |
6.560 kW |
5.493 to 7.271 |
6.445 |
pass |
| 680 |
annual_heating |
2.227 MWh |
1.210 to 3.080 |
2.056 |
pass |
| 680 |
annual_cooling |
6.136 MWh |
5.130 to 7.700 |
6.264 |
pass |
| 680 |
peak_heating |
2.013 kW |
1.672 to 2.232 |
1.984 |
pass |
| 680 |
peak_cooling |
6.518 kW |
5.408 to 7.404 |
6.446 |
pass |
| 685 |
annual_heating |
4.932 MWh |
4.080 to 5.750 |
4.762 |
pass |
| 685 |
annual_cooling |
8.946 MWh |
7.700 to 10.140 |
8.886 |
pass |
| 685 |
peak_heating |
3.225 kW |
2.863 to 3.543 |
3.183 |
pass |
| 685 |
peak_cooling |
6.932 kW |
5.713 to 7.517 |
6.743 |
pass |
| 695 |
annual_heating |
2.768 MWh |
1.700 to 3.810 |
2.656 |
pass |
| 695 |
annual_cooling |
8.754 MWh |
7.490 to 10.580 |
8.912 |
pass |
| 695 |
peak_heating |
2.047 kW |
1.688 to 2.245 |
2.001 |
pass |
| 695 |
peak_cooling |
7.080 kW |
5.855 to 7.918 |
6.979 |
pass |
| 900 |
annual_heating |
1.718 MWh |
1.040 to 2.280 |
1.627 |
pass |
| 900 |
annual_cooling |
2.395 MWh |
2.350 to 2.600 |
2.467 |
pass |
| 900 |
peak_heating |
2.668 kW |
2.304 to 2.917 |
2.591 |
pass |
| 900 |
peak_cooling |
2.974 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.975 |
pass |
| 910 |
annual_heating |
1.887 MWh |
1.560 to 2.300 |
1.971 |
pass |
| 910 |
annual_cooling |
1.615 MWh |
0.860 to 2.000 |
1.374 |
pass |
| 910 |
peak_heating |
2.676 kW |
2.329 to 2.939 |
2.648 |
pass |
| 910 |
peak_cooling |
2.280 kW |
1.945 to 2.858 |
2.305 |
pass |
| 920 |
annual_heating |
3.324 MWh |
2.550 to 4.200 |
3.326 |
pass |
| 920 |
annual_cooling |
2.663 MWh |
2.430 to 3.080 |
2.786 |
pass |
| 920 |
peak_heating |
2.743 kW |
2.367 to 3.040 |
2.710 |
pass |
| 920 |
peak_cooling |
3.223 kW |
2.536 to 3.655 |
3.127 |
pass |
| 930 |
annual_heating |
3.745 MWh |
2.750 to 5.350 |
4.064 |
pass |
| 930 |
annual_cooling |
2.177 MWh |
1.240 to 2.640 |
1.898 |
pass |
| 930 |
peak_heating |
2.753 kW |
2.389 to 3.116 |
2.751 |
pass |
| 930 |
peak_cooling |
2.869 kW |
2.182 to 3.205 |
2.656 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_heating |
1.100 MWh |
0.220 to 1.910 |
1.109 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_cooling |
2.329 MWh |
2.240 to 3.140 |
2.401 |
pass |
| 940 |
peak_heating |
3.274 kW |
2.858 to 4.076 |
3.377 |
pass |
| 940 |
peak_cooling |
2.974 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.993 |
pass |
| 950 |
annual_heating |
0.000 MWh |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 950 |
annual_cooling |
0.717 MWh |
0.430 to 1.520 |
0.634 |
pass |
| 950 |
peak_heating |
0.000 kW |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 950 |
peak_cooling |
2.385 kW |
1.935 to 2.507 |
2.268 |
pass |
| 960 |
annual_heating |
2.588 MWh |
2.000 to 3.400 |
2.693 |
pass |
| 960 |
annual_cooling |
0.950 MWh |
0.620 to 1.810 |
0.896 |
pass |
| 960 |
peak_heating |
2.104 kW |
1.970 to 2.415 |
2.195 |
pass |
| 960 |
peak_cooling |
1.475 kW |
1.264 to 1.554 |
1.393 |
pass |
| 960 |
maximum_temperature |
48.036 degC |
47.100 to 54.200 |
49.920 |
pass |
| 960 |
minimum_temperature |
4.160 degC |
3.200 to 9.000 |
5.800 |
pass |
| 960 |
mean_temperature |
26.693 degC |
25.800 to 30.500 |
28.060 |
pass |
| 980 |
annual_heating |
0.441 MWh |
-0.610 to 1.280 |
0.407 |
pass |
| 980 |
annual_cooling |
3.415 MWh |
3.520 to 4.490 |
3.710 |
known deviation: Buildings' own Case980 gives 3.418 MWh, 3 % below the lower limit of the standard (3.52 MWh); trano reproduces the library's model. |
| 980 |
peak_heating |
1.538 kW |
1.169 to 1.778 |
1.489 |
pass |
| 980 |
peak_cooling |
3.296 kW |
2.747 to 3.851 |
3.348 |
pass |
| 985 |
annual_heating |
2.371 MWh |
1.680 to 3.090 |
2.398 |
pass |
| 985 |
annual_cooling |
6.140 MWh |
5.950 to 7.260 |
6.351 |
pass |
| 985 |
peak_heating |
2.666 kW |
2.313 to 2.924 |
2.631 |
pass |
| 985 |
peak_cooling |
3.863 kW |
2.997 to 4.436 |
3.824 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_heating |
0.984 MWh |
-0.150 to 2.020 |
0.974 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_cooling |
6.789 MWh |
6.580 to 8.410 |
7.145 |
pass |
| 995 |
peak_heating |
1.598 kW |
1.284 to 1.797 |
1.565 |
pass |
| 995 |
peak_cooling |
3.973 kW |
3.104 to 4.435 |
3.986 |
pass |
| 600FF |
maximum_temperature |
63.318 degC |
61.400 to 69.400 |
64.600 |
pass |
| 600FF |
minimum_temperature |
-12.847 degC |
-14.800 to -8.900 |
-12.700 |
pass |
| 600FF |
mean_temperature |
24.664 degC |
23.300 to 27.100 |
25.250 |
pass |
| 650FF |
maximum_temperature |
62.135 degC |
60.100 to 67.800 |
63.067 |
pass |
| 650FF |
minimum_temperature |
-16.922 degC |
-18.800 to -15.700 |
-17.333 |
pass |
| 650FF |
mean_temperature |
18.733 degC |
16.600 to 19.900 |
18.300 |
pass |
| 680FF |
maximum_temperature |
68.913 degC |
68.800 to 79.500 |
73.017 |
pass |
| 680FF |
minimum_temperature |
-7.313 degC |
-9.100 to -4.700 |
-6.867 |
pass |
| 680FF |
mean_temperature |
30.137 degC |
29.200 to 34.300 |
31.850 |
pass |
| 900FF |
maximum_temperature |
43.840 degC |
42.300 to 47.000 |
44.583 |
pass |
| 900FF |
minimum_temperature |
1.107 degC |
-0.400 to 3.200 |
1.250 |
pass |
| 900FF |
mean_temperature |
24.932 degC |
23.500 to 26.700 |
25.233 |
pass |
| 950FF |
maximum_temperature |
36.790 degC |
35.100 to 38.100 |
36.583 |
pass |
| 950FF |
minimum_temperature |
-12.046 degC |
-14.400 to -11.500 |
-12.983 |
pass |
| 950FF |
mean_temperature |
15.243 degC |
13.400 to 16.000 |
14.733 |
pass |
| 980FF |
maximum_temperature |
48.664 degC |
47.500 to 53.800 |
50.500 |
pass |
| 980FF |
minimum_temperature |
9.634 degC |
6.300 to 13.500 |
10.350 |
pass |
| 980FF |
mean_temperature |
30.470 degC |
29.500 to 34.300 |
31.800 |
pass |
IDEAS
| Case |
KPI |
trano |
Band |
Reference mean |
Status |
| 600 |
annual_heating |
4.541 MWh |
3.750 to 4.980 |
4.213 |
pass |
| 600 |
annual_cooling |
6.265 MWh |
5.000 to 6.830 |
5.856 |
pass |
| 600 |
peak_heating |
3.314 kW |
2.852 to 3.527 |
3.183 |
pass |
| 600 |
peak_cooling |
6.545 kW |
5.098 to 6.805 |
6.024 |
pass |
| 620 |
annual_heating |
4.727 MWh |
3.670 to 5.380 |
4.413 |
pass |
| 620 |
annual_cooling |
4.235 MWh |
2.760 to 5.190 |
4.090 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_heating |
3.373 kW |
2.869 to 3.554 |
3.186 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_cooling |
4.908 kW |
3.715 to 5.037 |
4.526 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_heating |
2.769 MWh |
1.580 to 3.760 |
2.612 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_cooling |
6.009 MWh |
4.440 to 6.860 |
5.636 |
pass |
| 640 |
peak_heating |
4.370 kW |
3.806 to 4.891 |
4.369 |
pass |
| 640 |
peak_cooling |
6.491 kW |
5.044 to 6.750 |
5.973 |
pass |
| 650 |
annual_heating |
0.000 MWh |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 650 |
annual_cooling |
5.067 MWh |
3.460 to 5.880 |
4.644 |
pass |
| 650 |
peak_heating |
0.000 kW |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 650 |
peak_cooling |
6.324 kW |
4.731 to 6.604 |
5.813 |
pass |
| 660 |
annual_heating |
3.723 MWh |
2.680 to 4.820 |
3.713 |
pass |
| 660 |
annual_cooling |
3.438 MWh |
1.910 to 4.330 |
3.172 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_heating |
2.759 kW |
2.472 to 3.103 |
2.801 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_cooling |
3.873 kW |
3.146 to 4.130 |
3.565 |
pass |
| 670 |
annual_heating |
6.119 MWh |
4.000 to 7.960 |
5.681 |
pass |
| 670 |
annual_cooling |
6.683 MWh |
5.050 to 7.670 |
6.402 |
pass |
| 670 |
peak_heating |
4.166 kW |
3.444 to 4.432 |
3.943 |
pass |
| 670 |
peak_cooling |
6.899 kW |
5.493 to 7.271 |
6.445 |
pass |
| 680 |
annual_heating |
2.359 MWh |
1.210 to 3.080 |
2.056 |
pass |
| 680 |
annual_cooling |
6.642 MWh |
5.130 to 7.700 |
6.264 |
pass |
| 680 |
peak_heating |
2.144 kW |
1.672 to 2.232 |
1.984 |
pass |
| 680 |
peak_cooling |
6.964 kW |
5.408 to 7.404 |
6.446 |
pass |
| 685 |
annual_heating |
5.024 MWh |
4.080 to 5.750 |
4.762 |
pass |
| 685 |
annual_cooling |
9.271 MWh |
7.700 to 10.140 |
8.886 |
pass |
| 685 |
peak_heating |
3.329 kW |
2.863 to 3.543 |
3.183 |
pass |
| 685 |
peak_cooling |
7.282 kW |
5.713 to 7.517 |
6.743 |
pass |
| 695 |
annual_heating |
2.927 MWh |
1.700 to 3.810 |
2.656 |
pass |
| 695 |
annual_cooling |
9.316 MWh |
7.490 to 10.580 |
8.912 |
pass |
| 695 |
peak_heating |
2.185 kW |
1.688 to 2.245 |
2.001 |
pass |
| 695 |
peak_cooling |
7.527 kW |
5.855 to 7.918 |
6.979 |
pass |
| 900 |
annual_heating |
1.763 MWh |
1.040 to 2.280 |
1.627 |
pass |
| 900 |
annual_cooling |
2.599 MWh |
2.350 to 2.600 |
2.467 |
pass |
| 900 |
peak_heating |
2.765 kW |
2.304 to 2.917 |
2.591 |
pass |
| 900 |
peak_cooling |
3.171 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.975 |
pass |
| 920 |
annual_heating |
3.493 MWh |
2.550 to 4.200 |
3.326 |
pass |
| 920 |
annual_cooling |
2.820 MWh |
2.430 to 3.080 |
2.786 |
pass |
| 920 |
peak_heating |
2.861 kW |
2.367 to 3.040 |
2.710 |
pass |
| 920 |
peak_cooling |
3.388 kW |
2.536 to 3.655 |
3.127 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_heating |
1.126 MWh |
0.220 to 1.910 |
1.109 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_cooling |
2.524 MWh |
2.240 to 3.140 |
2.401 |
pass |
| 940 |
peak_heating |
3.253 kW |
2.858 to 4.076 |
3.377 |
pass |
| 940 |
peak_cooling |
3.170 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.993 |
pass |
| 950 |
annual_heating |
0.000 MWh |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 950 |
annual_cooling |
0.741 MWh |
0.430 to 1.520 |
0.634 |
pass |
| 950 |
peak_heating |
0.000 kW |
0.000 to 0.000 |
0.000 |
pass |
| 950 |
peak_cooling |
2.519 kW |
1.935 to 2.507 |
2.268 |
known deviation: 2.517 kW against a band ending at 2.507 kW (the spread of the reference programs plus 5 % of the largest peak): 0.4 % above a tolerance that is a convention, not a limit of the standard. |
| 960 |
annual_heating |
2.695 MWh |
2.000 to 3.400 |
2.693 |
pass |
| 960 |
annual_cooling |
0.950 MWh |
0.620 to 1.810 |
0.896 |
pass |
| 960 |
peak_heating |
2.217 kW |
1.970 to 2.415 |
2.195 |
pass |
| 960 |
peak_cooling |
1.510 kW |
1.264 to 1.554 |
1.393 |
pass |
| 960 |
maximum_temperature |
51.310 degC |
47.100 to 54.200 |
49.920 |
pass |
| 960 |
minimum_temperature |
4.133 degC |
3.200 to 9.000 |
5.800 |
pass |
| 960 |
mean_temperature |
28.027 degC |
25.800 to 30.500 |
28.060 |
pass |
| 980 |
annual_heating |
0.480 MWh |
-0.610 to 1.280 |
0.407 |
pass |
| 980 |
annual_cooling |
3.798 MWh |
3.520 to 4.490 |
3.710 |
pass |
| 980 |
peak_heating |
1.663 kW |
1.169 to 1.778 |
1.489 |
pass |
| 980 |
peak_cooling |
3.607 kW |
2.747 to 3.851 |
3.348 |
pass |
| 985 |
annual_heating |
2.464 MWh |
1.680 to 3.090 |
2.398 |
pass |
| 985 |
annual_cooling |
6.474 MWh |
5.950 to 7.260 |
6.351 |
pass |
| 985 |
peak_heating |
2.763 kW |
2.313 to 2.924 |
2.631 |
pass |
| 985 |
peak_cooling |
4.025 kW |
2.997 to 4.436 |
3.824 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_heating |
1.063 MWh |
-0.150 to 2.020 |
0.974 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_cooling |
7.272 MWh |
6.580 to 8.410 |
7.145 |
pass |
| 995 |
peak_heating |
1.715 kW |
1.284 to 1.797 |
1.565 |
pass |
| 995 |
peak_cooling |
4.257 kW |
3.104 to 4.435 |
3.986 |
pass |
| 600FF |
maximum_temperature |
66.086 degC |
61.400 to 69.400 |
64.600 |
pass |
| 600FF |
minimum_temperature |
-13.193 degC |
-14.800 to -8.900 |
-12.700 |
pass |
| 600FF |
mean_temperature |
25.109 degC |
23.300 to 27.100 |
25.250 |
pass |
| 650FF |
maximum_temperature |
64.789 degC |
60.100 to 67.800 |
63.067 |
pass |
| 650FF |
minimum_temperature |
-16.889 degC |
-18.800 to -15.700 |
-17.333 |
pass |
| 650FF |
mean_temperature |
18.996 degC |
16.600 to 19.900 |
18.300 |
pass |
| 680FF |
maximum_temperature |
72.328 degC |
68.800 to 79.500 |
73.017 |
pass |
| 680FF |
minimum_temperature |
-8.063 degC |
-9.100 to -4.700 |
-6.867 |
pass |
| 680FF |
mean_temperature |
30.991 degC |
29.200 to 34.300 |
31.850 |
pass |
| 900FF |
maximum_temperature |
44.753 degC |
42.300 to 47.000 |
44.583 |
pass |
| 900FF |
minimum_temperature |
0.814 degC |
-0.400 to 3.200 |
1.250 |
pass |
| 900FF |
mean_temperature |
25.256 degC |
23.500 to 26.700 |
25.233 |
pass |
| 950FF |
maximum_temperature |
37.197 degC |
35.100 to 38.100 |
36.583 |
pass |
| 950FF |
minimum_temperature |
-12.061 degC |
-14.400 to -11.500 |
-12.983 |
pass |
| 950FF |
mean_temperature |
15.341 degC |
13.400 to 16.000 |
14.733 |
pass |
| 980FF |
maximum_temperature |
50.242 degC |
47.500 to 53.800 |
50.500 |
pass |
| 980FF |
minimum_temperature |
9.351 degC |
6.300 to 13.500 |
10.350 |
pass |
| 980FF |
mean_temperature |
31.131 degC |
29.500 to 34.300 |
31.800 |
pass |
iso_13790
| Case |
KPI |
trano |
Band |
Reference mean |
Status |
| 600 |
annual_heating |
3.122 MWh |
3.750 to 4.980 |
4.213 |
fail |
| 600 |
annual_cooling |
5.298 MWh |
5.000 to 6.830 |
5.856 |
pass |
| 600 |
peak_heating |
3.099 kW |
2.852 to 3.527 |
3.183 |
pass |
| 600 |
peak_cooling |
4.870 kW |
5.098 to 6.805 |
6.024 |
fail |
| 620 |
annual_heating |
3.920 MWh |
3.670 to 5.380 |
4.413 |
pass |
| 620 |
annual_cooling |
3.777 MWh |
2.760 to 5.190 |
4.090 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_heating |
3.112 kW |
2.869 to 3.554 |
3.186 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_cooling |
4.328 kW |
3.715 to 5.037 |
4.526 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_heating |
1.879 MWh |
1.580 to 3.760 |
2.612 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_cooling |
4.942 MWh |
4.440 to 6.860 |
5.636 |
pass |
| 640 |
peak_heating |
4.350 kW |
3.806 to 4.891 |
4.369 |
pass |
| 640 |
peak_cooling |
4.870 kW |
5.044 to 6.750 |
5.973 |
fail |
| 660 |
annual_heating |
2.660 MWh |
2.680 to 4.820 |
3.713 |
fail |
| 660 |
annual_cooling |
2.612 MWh |
1.910 to 4.330 |
3.172 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_heating |
2.557 kW |
2.472 to 3.103 |
2.801 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_cooling |
3.078 kW |
3.146 to 4.130 |
3.565 |
fail |
| 670 |
annual_heating |
5.029 MWh |
4.000 to 7.960 |
5.681 |
pass |
| 670 |
annual_cooling |
4.901 MWh |
5.050 to 7.670 |
6.402 |
fail |
| 670 |
peak_heating |
4.045 kW |
3.444 to 4.432 |
3.943 |
pass |
| 670 |
peak_cooling |
5.015 kW |
5.493 to 7.271 |
6.445 |
fail |
| 680 |
annual_heating |
1.242 MWh |
1.210 to 3.080 |
2.056 |
pass |
| 680 |
annual_cooling |
6.451 MWh |
5.130 to 7.700 |
6.264 |
pass |
| 680 |
peak_heating |
2.096 kW |
1.672 to 2.232 |
1.984 |
pass |
| 680 |
peak_cooling |
5.138 kW |
5.408 to 7.404 |
6.446 |
fail |
| 685 |
annual_heating |
4.137 MWh |
4.080 to 5.750 |
4.762 |
pass |
| 685 |
annual_cooling |
9.344 MWh |
7.700 to 10.140 |
8.886 |
pass |
| 685 |
peak_heating |
3.090 kW |
2.863 to 3.543 |
3.183 |
pass |
| 685 |
peak_cooling |
5.754 kW |
5.713 to 7.517 |
6.743 |
pass |
| 695 |
annual_heating |
2.256 MWh |
1.700 to 3.810 |
2.656 |
pass |
| 695 |
annual_cooling |
10.030 MWh |
7.490 to 10.580 |
8.912 |
pass |
| 695 |
peak_heating |
2.090 kW |
1.688 to 2.245 |
2.001 |
pass |
| 695 |
peak_cooling |
6.030 kW |
5.855 to 7.918 |
6.979 |
pass |
| 900 |
annual_heating |
1.803 MWh |
1.040 to 2.280 |
1.627 |
pass |
| 900 |
annual_cooling |
3.581 MWh |
2.350 to 2.600 |
2.467 |
fail |
| 900 |
peak_heating |
2.880 kW |
2.304 to 2.917 |
2.591 |
pass |
| 900 |
peak_cooling |
3.532 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.975 |
pass |
| 920 |
annual_heating |
3.440 MWh |
2.550 to 4.200 |
3.326 |
pass |
| 920 |
annual_cooling |
3.264 MWh |
2.430 to 3.080 |
2.786 |
fail |
| 920 |
peak_heating |
2.933 kW |
2.367 to 3.040 |
2.710 |
pass |
| 920 |
peak_cooling |
3.535 kW |
2.536 to 3.655 |
3.127 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_heating |
1.276 MWh |
0.220 to 1.910 |
1.109 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_cooling |
3.498 MWh |
2.240 to 3.140 |
2.401 |
fail |
| 940 |
peak_heating |
4.156 kW |
2.858 to 4.076 |
3.377 |
fail |
| 940 |
peak_cooling |
3.531 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.993 |
pass |
| 980 |
annual_heating |
0.532 MWh |
-0.610 to 1.280 |
0.407 |
pass |
| 980 |
annual_cooling |
5.255 MWh |
3.520 to 4.490 |
3.710 |
fail |
| 980 |
peak_heating |
1.886 kW |
1.169 to 1.778 |
1.489 |
fail |
| 980 |
peak_cooling |
3.733 kW |
2.747 to 3.851 |
3.348 |
pass |
| 985 |
annual_heating |
2.730 MWh |
1.680 to 3.090 |
2.398 |
pass |
| 985 |
annual_cooling |
7.937 MWh |
5.950 to 7.260 |
6.351 |
fail |
| 985 |
peak_heating |
2.871 kW |
2.313 to 2.924 |
2.631 |
pass |
| 985 |
peak_cooling |
4.204 kW |
2.997 to 4.436 |
3.824 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_heating |
1.195 MWh |
-0.150 to 2.020 |
0.974 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_cooling |
8.954 MWh |
6.580 to 8.410 |
7.145 |
fail |
| 995 |
peak_heating |
1.886 kW |
1.284 to 1.797 |
1.565 |
fail |
| 995 |
peak_cooling |
4.228 kW |
3.104 to 4.435 |
3.986 |
pass |
| 600FF |
maximum_temperature |
54.174 degC |
61.400 to 69.400 |
64.600 |
fail |
| 600FF |
minimum_temperature |
-7.447 degC |
-14.800 to -8.900 |
-12.700 |
fail |
| 600FF |
mean_temperature |
26.564 degC |
23.300 to 27.100 |
25.250 |
pass |
| 680FF |
maximum_temperature |
61.503 degC |
68.800 to 79.500 |
73.017 |
fail |
| 680FF |
minimum_temperature |
-0.611 degC |
-9.100 to -4.700 |
-6.867 |
fail |
| 680FF |
mean_temperature |
33.913 degC |
29.200 to 34.300 |
31.850 |
pass |
| 900FF |
maximum_temperature |
47.038 degC |
42.300 to 47.000 |
44.583 |
fail |
| 900FF |
minimum_temperature |
0.045 degC |
-0.400 to 3.200 |
1.250 |
pass |
| 900FF |
mean_temperature |
26.610 degC |
23.500 to 26.700 |
25.233 |
pass |
| 980FF |
maximum_temperature |
54.832 degC |
47.500 to 53.800 |
50.500 |
fail |
| 980FF |
minimum_temperature |
8.231 degC |
6.300 to 13.500 |
10.350 |
pass |
| 980FF |
mean_temperature |
33.914 degC |
29.500 to 34.300 |
31.800 |
pass |
reduced_order
| Case |
KPI |
trano |
Band |
Reference mean |
Status |
| 600 |
annual_heating |
5.873 MWh |
3.750 to 4.980 |
4.213 |
fail |
| 600 |
annual_cooling |
3.883 MWh |
5.000 to 6.830 |
5.856 |
fail |
| 600 |
peak_heating |
3.731 kW |
2.852 to 3.527 |
3.183 |
fail |
| 600 |
peak_cooling |
4.113 kW |
5.098 to 6.805 |
6.024 |
fail |
| 620 |
annual_heating |
6.058 MWh |
3.670 to 5.380 |
4.413 |
fail |
| 620 |
annual_cooling |
2.786 MWh |
2.760 to 5.190 |
4.090 |
pass |
| 620 |
peak_heating |
3.731 kW |
2.869 to 3.554 |
3.186 |
fail |
| 620 |
peak_cooling |
3.926 kW |
3.715 to 5.037 |
4.526 |
pass |
| 640 |
annual_heating |
3.765 MWh |
1.580 to 3.760 |
2.612 |
fail |
| 640 |
annual_cooling |
3.791 MWh |
4.440 to 6.860 |
5.636 |
fail |
| 640 |
peak_heating |
3.445 kW |
3.806 to 4.891 |
4.369 |
fail |
| 640 |
peak_cooling |
4.103 kW |
5.044 to 6.750 |
5.973 |
fail |
| 660 |
annual_heating |
4.580 MWh |
2.680 to 4.820 |
3.713 |
pass |
| 660 |
annual_cooling |
2.249 MWh |
1.910 to 4.330 |
3.172 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_heating |
2.956 kW |
2.472 to 3.103 |
2.801 |
pass |
| 660 |
peak_cooling |
2.614 kW |
3.146 to 4.130 |
3.565 |
fail |
| 670 |
annual_heating |
10.069 MWh |
4.000 to 7.960 |
5.681 |
fail |
| 670 |
annual_cooling |
2.934 MWh |
5.050 to 7.670 |
6.402 |
fail |
| 670 |
peak_heating |
5.726 kW |
3.444 to 4.432 |
3.943 |
fail |
| 670 |
peak_cooling |
4.186 kW |
5.493 to 7.271 |
6.445 |
fail |
| 680 |
annual_heating |
3.726 MWh |
1.210 to 3.080 |
2.056 |
fail |
| 680 |
annual_cooling |
4.529 MWh |
5.130 to 7.700 |
6.264 |
fail |
| 680 |
peak_heating |
2.603 kW |
1.672 to 2.232 |
1.984 |
fail |
| 680 |
peak_cooling |
4.501 kW |
5.408 to 7.404 |
6.446 |
fail |
| 685 |
annual_heating |
5.970 MWh |
4.080 to 5.750 |
4.762 |
fail |
| 685 |
annual_cooling |
6.378 MWh |
7.700 to 10.140 |
8.886 |
fail |
| 685 |
peak_heating |
3.714 kW |
2.863 to 3.543 |
3.183 |
fail |
| 685 |
peak_cooling |
4.846 kW |
5.713 to 7.517 |
6.743 |
fail |
| 695 |
annual_heating |
3.811 MWh |
1.700 to 3.810 |
2.656 |
fail |
| 695 |
annual_cooling |
6.549 MWh |
7.490 to 10.580 |
8.912 |
fail |
| 695 |
peak_heating |
2.590 kW |
1.688 to 2.245 |
2.001 |
fail |
| 695 |
peak_cooling |
5.054 kW |
5.855 to 7.918 |
6.979 |
fail |
| 900 |
annual_heating |
5.263 MWh |
1.040 to 2.280 |
1.627 |
fail |
| 900 |
annual_cooling |
3.184 MWh |
2.350 to 2.600 |
2.467 |
fail |
| 900 |
peak_heating |
3.726 kW |
2.304 to 2.917 |
2.591 |
fail |
| 900 |
peak_cooling |
3.631 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.975 |
fail |
| 920 |
annual_heating |
5.632 MWh |
2.550 to 4.200 |
3.326 |
fail |
| 920 |
annual_cooling |
2.343 MWh |
2.430 to 3.080 |
2.786 |
fail |
| 920 |
peak_heating |
3.726 kW |
2.367 to 3.040 |
2.710 |
fail |
| 920 |
peak_cooling |
3.492 kW |
2.536 to 3.655 |
3.127 |
pass |
| 940 |
annual_heating |
3.321 MWh |
0.220 to 1.910 |
1.109 |
fail |
| 940 |
annual_cooling |
3.059 MWh |
2.240 to 3.140 |
2.401 |
pass |
| 940 |
peak_heating |
3.187 kW |
2.858 to 4.076 |
3.377 |
pass |
| 940 |
peak_cooling |
3.611 kW |
2.387 to 3.545 |
2.993 |
fail |
| 980 |
annual_heating |
3.665 MWh |
-0.610 to 1.280 |
0.407 |
fail |
| 980 |
annual_cooling |
4.460 MWh |
3.520 to 4.490 |
3.710 |
pass |
| 980 |
peak_heating |
2.603 kW |
1.169 to 1.778 |
1.489 |
fail |
| 980 |
peak_cooling |
4.444 kW |
2.747 to 3.851 |
3.348 |
fail |
| 985 |
annual_heating |
5.444 MWh |
1.680 to 3.090 |
2.398 |
fail |
| 985 |
annual_cooling |
5.848 MWh |
5.950 to 7.260 |
6.351 |
fail |
| 985 |
peak_heating |
3.709 kW |
2.313 to 2.924 |
2.631 |
fail |
| 985 |
peak_cooling |
4.414 kW |
2.997 to 4.436 |
3.824 |
pass |
| 995 |
annual_heating |
3.763 MWh |
-0.150 to 2.020 |
0.974 |
fail |
| 995 |
annual_cooling |
6.487 MWh |
6.580 to 8.410 |
7.145 |
fail |
| 995 |
peak_heating |
2.590 kW |
1.284 to 1.797 |
1.565 |
fail |
| 995 |
peak_cooling |
5.006 kW |
3.104 to 4.435 |
3.986 |
fail |
| 600FF |
maximum_temperature |
62.110 degC |
61.400 to 69.400 |
64.600 |
pass |
| 600FF |
minimum_temperature |
-14.177 degC |
-14.800 to -8.900 |
-12.700 |
pass |
| 600FF |
mean_temperature |
20.451 degC |
23.300 to 27.100 |
25.250 |
fail |
| 680FF |
maximum_temperature |
78.794 degC |
68.800 to 79.500 |
73.017 |
pass |
| 680FF |
minimum_temperature |
-11.117 degC |
-9.100 to -4.700 |
-6.867 |
fail |
| 680FF |
mean_temperature |
24.262 degC |
29.200 to 34.300 |
31.850 |
fail |
| 900FF |
maximum_temperature |
56.089 degC |
42.300 to 47.000 |
44.583 |
fail |
| 900FF |
minimum_temperature |
-10.040 degC |
-0.400 to 3.200 |
1.250 |
fail |
| 900FF |
mean_temperature |
20.461 degC |
23.500 to 26.700 |
25.233 |
fail |
| 980FF |
maximum_temperature |
77.475 degC |
47.500 to 53.800 |
50.500 |
fail |
| 980FF |
minimum_temperature |
-9.062 degC |
6.300 to 13.500 |
10.350 |
fail |
| 980FF |
mean_temperature |
24.248 degC |
29.500 to 34.300 |
31.800 |
fail |